The Truth About Cooking Fats

By Tom Seest

Is Shortening Really Just Vegetable Oil?

At SeedOilNews, we help people who are curious about seed oil by collating information and news about seed oils.

Ree Drummond keeps several essential pantry items on hand, like vegetable shortening. Shortening is an odorless and flavorless product with zero water content; solid at room temperature but easily melts when used for baking or frying recipes.
Shortening is known to have a high smoke point and non-splattering characteristics when heated, making it the ideal product to use for greasing pans. Furthermore, production costs are low, and refrigeration is not necessary.

Is Shortening Really Just Vegetable Oil?

Is Shortening Really Just Vegetable Oil?

What Makes Vegetable Oil Essential for Cooking?

Vegetable oil is an extremely popular cooking ingredient. Its many advantages make it suitable for almost every recipe imaginable: low cost, high smoke point and neutral flavor make it versatile enough for everyday use. Furthermore, vegetable oils can come from any number of plants; sometimes blended together specifically for particular cooking applications resulting in bottle to bottle variation in their plant source.
Vegetable oil is an all-encompassing term that refers to any plant-derived oil found in foodstuffs. It may be liquid or solid at room temperature and typically sold in bottles that feature clear labels listing its name and chemical constituents.
Vegetable oil can be extracted from seeds, nuts, or other parts of plants either through mechanical means (cracking open a nut and pressing out its oil) or chemical means to break down fats found within it.
Canola oil is one of the most commonly consumed vegetable oils in Australia. While most vegetable oils come from the rapeseed plant, others may contain other forms, such as soybean, corn, or palm oils in their composition. While canola may come packaged in glass containers with instructions for usage and nutritional data attached, others are stored in plastic bottles with labels detailing this information and how best to utilize the product.
Vegetable shortening is a solid fat made of vegetable or animal-based oils, often hydrogenated for increased shelf stability and decreased iodine values. It is most frequently used in baking and cooking applications; for instance it helps prevent pies from sticking, stabilize icings, and prevent baked goods from spreading too much during baking. Similar to pork-derived lard, vegetable shortening contains saturated fats. Shortening may also be hydrogenated to lower its iodine values and enhance shelf stability; it can even be found in salad dressings and certain mayonnaises.

What Makes Vegetable Oil Essential for Cooking?

What Makes Vegetable Oil Essential for Cooking?

How Does Shortening Differ from Vegetable Oil?

Shortening is a solid fat used in baking recipes to give pastries their creamy texture. It may be made from animal fat (lard or beef tallow) or vegetable oils such as cottonseed or palm oil, and partially or fully hydrogenated, meaning its fatty acid chains have been saturated with hydrogen atoms to reduce spoilage risk and lengthen shelf life compared with unhydrogenated oils.
Regular shortening does not have a distinct flavor, making it suitable for use in both sweet and savory recipes. With its neutral taste, regular shortening makes an ideal ingredient in biscuits, cornbread and scones – although some dishes rely heavily on butter-flavored dishes; substituting regular shortening for this can result in bland tasting dishes; to avoid this situation there are shortening substitutes available to chefs looking for alternatives.
Some people opt to use margarine in place of shortening, and it can make for an excellent option in many recipes. Margarine contains more water than shortening, meaning that it melts more easily and has a lighter texture; furthermore, margarine does not contain trans fats that may be found in shortening products.
Coconut oil is another popular alternative to vegetable shortening. With its tropical flavor and high concentration of monounsaturated fats – considered healthy fats – coconut oil offers many of the same advantages in baking recipes as vegetable shortening. Unfortunately, however, many cooks find that its use in recipes doesn’t perform quite as well and cannot withstand high temperatures as easily, presenting difficulties when trying to incorporate into batters.

How Does Shortening Differ from Vegetable Oil?

How Does Shortening Differ from Vegetable Oil?

Are Shortening and Vegetable Oil Interchangeable?

If you find that you’ve run out of shortening and still want to complete a recipe that calls for it, using butter as an alternative would provide similar flavor and texture without adding extra fat or calories – perfect if trying to limit artificial trans fat intake!
Olive oil can serve as an alternative to shortening, though its performance in baking might not match that of butter. Olive oil might alter the overall texture of recipes so should only be used when frying or sauteing food items.
Peanut or sunflower seed oils may also serve as effective alternatives to shortening for frying, as these types of oils tend to heat quickly at higher temperatures and will help ensure that food does not stick to the pan.
Applesauce can serve as an effective shortening alternative and healthy replacement to vegetable oil in many recipes, adding natural sweetness without changing their taste; however, be aware that using applesauce will cause densification of the final product.
Coconut oil makes an excellent shortening replacement. It melts at warmer temperatures, making it healthier than many other cooking oils and offering a flaky yet rich texture to baked goods like biscuits or pie crusts that require shortening.

Are Shortening and Vegetable Oil Interchangeable?

Are Shortening and Vegetable Oil Interchangeable?

Is Shortening a Better Substitute for Butter?

Many baking recipes require shortening as an ingredient, however its high fat content may put some people off. If this is the case for you, there are various alternatives you can try in its place; one option being butter. Butter’s similarity to shortening makes it ideal for use across a range of recipes, while margarine provides another great substitute option that still provides a similar texture and results in shortening. Both ingredients should work as effective replacements, but be aware that they may produce slightly different outcomes when used instead of being shortened for baking purposes!
If you’re in search of a more healthy alternative to vegetable shortening, coconut oil might just be what you need. Although coconut oil has gained some notoriety as a health food, it should be remembered that it contains high levels of saturated fats. Furthermore, its very low melting point may make working with this oil difficult.
Applesauce can serve as an effective shortening substitute, though some might find this surprising. While applesauce is generally healthier due to having zero fat content, but keep in mind that its sugar content could alter the outcome of any recipe you create with it.
Overall, it is essential to remember that there is no exact replacement for shortening when baking. For optimal results, follow your recipe as closely as possible for best results.

Is Shortening a Better Substitute for Butter?

Is Shortening a Better Substitute for Butter?

Is Shortening Better Than Vegetable Oil for Baking?

As an alternative to shortening in deep-frying recipes, many chefs turn to vegetable oils like peanut, sunflower seed, olive, sesame and canola oil for substituting shortening. Since they all offer neutral flavors that make for good shortening replacement options in most instances.
However, some bakers prefer butter as an alternative to shortening because it lends baked goods a richer flavor – particularly cookies which benefit from butter’s buttery flavor being used instead.
Another popular shortening alternative is lard, commonly referred to as suet. Lard is generally made up of non-hydrogenated fats; however, due to high levels of saturated fats, it should only be used sparingly. Furthermore, certain recipes may not work with either substance as their distinctive flavors may make the final product unappetizing.
Olive oil makes an excellent shortening replacement, thanks to its healthful content and abundant Vitamin E sources. Olive oil also boasts similar texture as shortening, making it easy for baking enthusiasts. But please be mindful that its taste may differ significantly – best used in savory recipes only; plus it alters baked goods by densifying their structure – something to bear in mind when planning recipes!

Is Shortening Better Than Vegetable Oil for Baking?

Is Shortening Better Than Vegetable Oil for Baking?

Be sure to read our other related stories at SeedOilNews to learn more about seed oils.